Sandwiched between two lakes, Madison's isthmus creates daily gridlock that locals have complained about for decades. Should we accept the geography and move on, or demand real engineering solutions before another road diet gets approved?
Join the debate to comment
Reading is free. Members pay to post — that's why it stays clean.
Add your commentCan we talk about how the BRT project that's supposedly going to save us all has been in some form of planning purgatory since before COVID? At this point I consider it a local myth, like a transit Bigfoot. People swear they've seen evidence of it but I'm not convinced it actually exists.
Born and raised on the near east side. My dad complained about John Nolen Drive traffic in the 80s. My kids will complain about it in the 2040s. The lakes aren't moving. At some point we have to accept that Madison is a city physically designed to drive everyone insane and just... take the bus.
My favorite Madison tradition: complain about traffic on the isthmus, vote against any transit referendum, buy a bigger car, repeat. We did this to ourselves folks.
To the person asking about a new bridge — they HAVE discussed it. Multiple times. Over multiple decades. The problem is you'd have to either tear through established neighborhoods or deal with wetland protections around both lakes that make permitting an absolute nightmare. It's not that planners are dumb, it's that the legal and environmental hurdles are genuinely enormous. I used to work adjacent to the city engineering office and the amount of federal review alone would take 15+ years.
I ride my bike from Williamson Street to the Capitol every single day and the infrastructure has genuinely gotten better in the last decade. Maybe stop designing the city around single-occupancy vehicles and you'd stop being surprised that single-occupancy vehicles are miserable to drive? Just a thought from someone who hasn't sat in gridlock since 2019.
Not trying hard enough. Full stop. Every other mid-size city with geographic constraints has found creative solutions — tunnels, elevated transit, dedicated bus rapid transit corridors. Madison planners spend half the budget on studies and the other half on rebranding the studies. I've attended three public input sessions in five years and nothing has changed except the PowerPoint templates.
Honestly? The road diets are the problem. Someone in city planning decided that removing car lanes everywhere was visionary urbanism and now Blair Street turns into a parking lot every morning. I don't care if that's an unpopular opinion at a dinner party in Vilas — it's true.
I actually sat down and looked at the traffic data that the city published last spring — peak congestion on the isthmus is measurably worse than comparable geography cities like Annapolis and Burlington VT, both of which also have water constraints. The difference is those cities invested heavily in park-and-ride infrastructure on their peripheries decades ago. Madison keeps talking about it. Madison does not do it. That's a planning failure, not a geography failure.
I moved away to Denver in 2018 and came back to visit last month. Drove through downtown during what I guess was just a normal Tuesday afternoon and genuinely could not believe how bad it still was on East Washington. You have one corridor in and out and approximately one million UW events happening simultaneously. There is no engineering solution for that. The geography won.
ok genuine question for anyone who actually knows: can't they just build a third bridge connecting something like the Yahara corridor to the west side? i moved here two years ago from Indianapolis and i genuinely cannot believe this hasn't been discussed seriously. someone explain why this isn't happening
my commute from stoughton road to west towne takes 47 minutes on a good day. 47 minutes. thats not geography thats a policy choice and im tired of people acting like we just have to suffer because of two lakes that have existed since the ice age
Okay I'll be the contrarian here: the isthmus traffic isn't actually that bad compared to real cities. I spent six years in the DC suburbs before landing here in 2020. You people have never experienced true gridlock. You're complaining about a 15-minute backup like it's the apocalypse. Madison is still genuinely livable. Don't let perfect be the enemy of good — although yes, BRT should have been built already, I'll give you that one.
Is it wrong to choose not to have children just because you don't want to?
110 comments
Would you still eat meat if you had to kill the animal yourself?
109 comments
Are dating apps genuinely harder for men or for women?
108 comments
Should we genetically edit babies to remove diseases if we can?
108 comments