Locals either love the chaotic energy of State Street on a game night or avoid it like the plague after age 25. Is it still a cultural cornerstone of Madison life, or has it become an embarrassing cliché?
Join the debate to comment
Reading is free. Members pay to post — that's why it stays clean.
Add your commentEvery single Halloween on State Street I tell myself never again. Every single Halloween I end up on State Street. It is genuinely cursed and I love it against my will.
My hot take: State Street is for people aged 19-24 and tourists aged 45-65 who want to feel young. Everyone in between is just kind of passing through on the way to the Terrace.
Born and raised on the east side, and I'll die on this hill: State Street peaked sometime around 2003 and has been coasting on its reputation ever since. Half the storefronts are vape shops and overpriced ramen places now. The Orpheum is still great but everything else? Vibes. Just vibes.
As someone who moved away to Minneapolis six years ago and comes back to visit family twice a year — you locals genuinely do not appreciate what you have. State Street on a cool fall evening with a game on is one of the most alive, electric, genuinely American experiences I know. I'd move back tomorrow if the job market cooperated. Stop taking it for granted.
My grandpa used to take me to the old Steep & Brew on State Street when I was little while he read the paper. That place had more cultural soul in one corner booth than the entire strip has now. Miss it every time I walk past whatever chain replaced it.
I used to bartend at a place on State Street for four years — won't name it — and the tourists romanticizing it are not wrong exactly, they're just romanticizing a snapshot. What they see on a game weekend is real. What they don't see is the same six drunken arguments every single night, the cleanup crews at 3am, the staff getting stiffed by tables of 22-year-olds. It's a complicated place to actually work in.
Genuine question for the people calling it a "treasure" — when was the last time you actually went on a random Tuesday in September, sober, and just walked it end to end? Because I did that last fall and it was fine. Like, perfectly fine. A few good spots, some overpriced bars, nothing that would make a top-10 list anywhere. The magic is mostly alcohol-assisted.
^^ that fun fact about it being the longest pedestrian mall in the US is not correct, just so everyone knows. There are several longer ones. State Street is about eight blocks. Please don't spread this around.
Counterpoint nobody wants to hear: drunk college kids spending money on a Friday night is literally what keeps half those small businesses alive through January and February. The bar scene IS the economic engine. You can't have the cozy little bookstores and the funky art shops without the foot traffic the bars drag in. Hate to say it but it's true.
Anyone else remember when the Angelic Brewing Company was still there? Took my parents every single time they visited. That closure hit different. I don't think State Street has had a proper anchor since. Challenge to any local reading this — name me ONE current spot that has the same neighborhood institution energy. I'll wait.
The bar scene itself is fine. The PROBLEM is the infrastructure around it. Try finding a cab or even a rideshare after a Badgers game ends. My wife and I stood in the rain for 40 minutes on a November night because every Uber in a six block radius was surging at 4x. That's not charm, that's a city that hasn't figured out its own event logistics.
Fun fact: State Street is actually the longest pedestrian mall in the entire United States. So yeah, it's historically significant AND a good time. People acting like it's some embarrassing mess have clearly never been to Bourbon Street in New Orleans. THAT is a drunk mess. State Street is a slightly tipsy treasure.
state street is literally closed to cars. its pedestrian. its got live music. its got food. its got bars. what exactly is the problem here? i feel like madison people just love complaining about madison things
ok i just moved here from chicago for grad school and honestly??? state street is SO fun. you guys don't know what you have. try living somewhere with no walkable nightlife for five years and then tell me its embarrassing lol
Is it wrong to choose not to have children just because you don't want to?
110 comments
Would you still eat meat if you had to kill the animal yourself?
109 comments
Are dating apps genuinely harder for men or for women?
108 comments
Should we genetically edit babies to remove diseases if we can?
108 comments