Severance Season 2's finale left half the fanbase furious and the other half calling it genius — which side are you on?

• S
  Sam3d ago

  I work in corporate America and this show is a DOCUMENTARY. Change my mind.

  201
• S
  Sam3d ago

  I have genuinely never felt more manipulated by a television show in my life. I rearranged my entire Friday night to watch that finale live and I sat there at the end like... that's IT? That's what we waited for? I'm not even mad at the storytelling, I'm mad at myself for caring this much.

  187
• J
  Jordan2d ago

  my coworker spoiled the finale for me during a meeting and now I'm considering severance in real life

  178
• FK
  Feli K.1d ago

  The person above this is going to watch season 2 this weekend and they know it

  167
• MR
  Morgan R.2d ago

  Zach Cherry deserved more screen time every single season. That's my only note. Good day.

  156
• Z
  Zara2d ago

  Adam Scott is quietly doing some of the most emotionally complex acting on television and I feel like he gets zero awards attention because the show is too weird for academy voters to know what to do with. The scene in episode six alone should have been a submission reel.

  145
• AK
  Alex K.3d ago

  People complaining about the finale are exactly the type of audience that ruined prestige TV in the first place. You want everything handed to you in a bow. The whole POINT of Severance is that resolution is a lie the outside world sells you. The show IS the experience of being a Lumon employee. You don't get closure. That's the thesis.

  143
• R
  Riley1d ago

  I have a theory that people's reaction to the Severance finale is directly correlated to how much they like their job. People who feel trapped at work loved it. People who feel fine about their job thought it was overlong and pretentious. Small sample size, just something I noticed.

  139
• N
  Nina3d ago

  My husband and I started watching Severance together two years ago when we were going through a really rough patch at work — both of us feeling like we were leaving pieces of ourselves at the office every day. The show hit differently for us because of that. Season 2 captured something true about how work colonizes your identity even more than season 1 did. The finale made me cry and I couldn't even fully explain why to him.

  134
• OK
  Omar K.1d ago

  Season 3 better not take two more years or I will have completely emotionally moved on and no amount of good reviews will bring me back. That is a genuine threat directed at no one in particular.

  122
• ZL
  Zara L.2d ago

  The Empire Strikes Back comparison people use for every cliffhanger ending in television needs to be retired immediately. Empire had three complete character arcs, a resolved central conflict AND a cliffhanger. Those are not comparable situations.

  119
• TS
  Theo S.3d ago

  I think the issue is that season 1 had a very contained, elegant mystery and season 2 tried to expand the universe so much that it diluted what made the original special. More is not always more. The Lumon world worked because we only saw fragments of it.

  112
• F
  Feli1d ago

  What frustrates me is that season 1 had incredibly precise plotting — every detail meant something, every scene paid off. Season 2 introduced probably four major new mysteries and resolved approximately zero from either season. That's not a ratio that works. You have to give audiences SOMETHING.

  108
• J
  Jordan2d ago

  Season 2 had the single best episode of television I watched all year — you know which one — and also had three of the most boring episodes I watched all year. It's a deeply uneven season. The finale being divisive makes total sense because the season itself couldn't decide what it wanted to be.

  103
• L9
  Leo 923d ago

  The Gemma/Ms. Cobel storyline was completely wasted this season. She was the most interesting character in season 1 and they basically sidelined her for eight episodes and then remembered she existed in episode nine. That's bad writing, not bold storytelling.

  98
• DS
  Drew S.2d ago

  I've read like four different academic-style breakdowns of the finale and they all contradict each other completely. I'm not sure if that means the show is brilliantly ambiguous or just incoherent. Could genuinely be either.

  94
• K
  Kofi2d ago

  People keep saying the slow pace is intentional and artistic but there is a difference between deliberate pacing and just... not having enough plot to fill your episode count. At some point you have to be honest about which one it is.

  91
• Z
  Zara3d ago

  Anyone who thinks this finale was a masterpiece has not watched enough television. Twin Peaks: The Return finale was a masterpiece. This was a showrunner who wrote themselves into a corner and decided ambiguity was the same as depth. Those are very different things.

  89
• S
  Sam2d ago

  That take above is extremely online and also kind of brilliant and I hate it.

  88
• Z
  Zara2d ago

  The show is secretly about the gig economy and the fragmentation of worker identity under late capitalism. The severed vs. innie divide is literally just full time vs. contractor. Once you see it you can't unsee it and the finale lands completely differently.

  83
• A9
  Alex 921d ago

  I watched the finale twice and I genuinely think the last ten minutes are some of the best television made in the last five years. I also think episodes three and four were a complete waste of my time. Severance contains multitudes.

  77
• C
  Casey2d ago

  I don't understand why everyone is angry. The show was renewed for season 3. This was always going to be a middle chapter. Did people also flip tables after Empire Strikes Back?

  76
• T
  Taylor3d ago

  ok hot take but i think season 2 was actually better than season 1 overall and the finale was fine. people just hype themselves into impossible expectations and then blame the writers

  72
• J
  Jordan3d ago

  The cinematography alone justifies every decision they made. I don't care about plot resolution when every single frame looks like that. Ben Stiller has been one of the most underrated directors working in prestige television for years and nobody talks about it enough.

  67
• E
  Elena1d ago

  counter point: Lost gave audiences something every week and still had one of the most hated finales in television history. maybe trust is actually the point and not every thread needs tying

  62
• O
  Omar2d ago

  Genuinely curious what people who loved the finale think actually HAPPENED in it. Not being sarcastic. I want to understand what I missed because I felt like I watched something entirely different from what the positive reviewers described.

  57
• P
  Priya1d ago

  The music in this show has always been wildly underappreciated. Theodore Shapiro's score for the finale especially. Some of those cues did more emotional heavy lifting than the dialogue. Fight me.

  52
• M
  Maya3d ago

  lol at people calling a show on Apple TV+ prestige. its a tech company making content to sell subscriptions. the whole thing is a very expensive ad. the show literally takes place inside a corporation and you are paying a corporation to watch it. nobody thinks about this.

  44
• M
  Marco1d ago

  Patricia Arquette won a Golden Globe for this show and somehow people still act like it's underrated. It's extremely rated. Very appropriately rated. It's a good show that also has real problems. Both things.

  38
• T
  Theo3d ago

  Severance is filmed in New Jersey btw. Just something I think about.

  31
• EM
  Elena M.1d ago

  stopped watching after season 1 because I knew they could never top it. sounds like I made the right call based on this thread lmao

  29

More debates people can't stop arguing about