If you love someone enough to build a life with them, shouldn't they know exactly what you earn? Or is financial privacy a basic human right that survives even the deepest romantic relationship?
Join the debate to comment
Reading is free. Members pay to post — that's why it stays clean.
Add your commentI've been married twice. First husband insisted on total financial transparency, every penny accounted for, joint everything. Turned out he was using that access to control where I went, what I wore, who I saw. My second husband and I keep separate accounts. We split household costs proportionally and we are the happiest we've ever been. Sometimes "full transparency" is just control wearing a nice sweater.
My parents kept separate accounts their entire 47-year marriage. My dad died last year. My mom told me she always knew roughly what he made, they just liked the autonomy. The idea that this makes them "not truly committed" is honestly insulting to their memory. Commitment shows up in how you treat each other every single day, not in whether you share a Chase login.
My ex hid that he had a whole second income stream. Like a significant freelance business bringing in extra money every month. We were "too broke" for vacations, for fixing the car properly, for me to go back to school. Reader, we were not too broke. We were divorced within a year of me finding out. So yeah. The hiding part matters.
I think people are missing the real issue which is TRUST not ACCOUNTS. You can have a joint account and lie constantly. You can have separate accounts and be completely honest. The bank account structure is just logistics. What matters is whether you're being deceptive about your financial reality when it affects shared decisions.
I'll say what nobody wants to: a lot of people keep separate finances because they're planning for the relationship to potentially end. That's not commitment, that's hedging. And that's fine! People are allowed to hedge! But let's not pretend it's the same thing as going all in.
ok but if youre hiding your FULL salary from your partner that IS a red flag tho. like there's a difference between having your own spending account and actively concealing what you make. one is healthy independence, the other is... suspicious at best
Going "all in" on finances with someone is how millions of people end up financially devastated after divorce or the death of a partner. Especially women. Especially older women. Financial independence isn't betrayal, it's survival strategy built from watching what happens to other people.
I keep coming back to the word "truly" in the topic title. Truly committed. As if there's some pure platonic ideal of commitment and anything short of total financial merger is a lesser version. Life is messier than that. Commitment is a practice, not a purity test.
Counterpoint to the person who mentioned controlling partners — yes, financial abuse is real and separate accounts can protect people in those situations. But that's an argument against ABUSIVE partners, not an argument against financial transparency in HEALTHY relationships. We shouldn't design the rules for healthy relationships around the worst-case scenario.
The word "hiding" is doing a LOT of heavy lifting in this debate. Choosing not to disclose isn't the same as hiding. I choose not to disclose my medical history to coworkers. That doesn't mean I'm hiding it.
Wait someone above said financial secrecy correlates with breakdown — I'd push back on that slightly. Correlation isn't causation. Couples who are already emotionally distant are MORE LIKELY to have financial secrecy. The underlying issue is the distance, not the bank accounts themselves. Fixing the accounts without fixing the relationship doesn't fix anything.
The statement says "not TRULY committed" which is so vague as to be meaningless. Committed to what exactly? I am committed to my husband's wellbeing, his happiness, growing old together, raising our kids well. My salary is mine. These things coexist just fine.
Actually, legally speaking, in most community property jurisdictions both spouses already have a legal claim to income earned during marriage regardless of whose account it goes into. So "hiding" your salary from your spouse in those places is kind of legally incoherent anyway. The romantic question and the legal question are totally separate of course but it's worth knowing.
my husband doesnt know exactly what i make and honestly he doesnt care lol. we each pay our agreed share of everything, we have savings goals we work toward together, we never fight about money. why would we change this? the system works. not everything needs to be a whole political statement about commitment
Every financial advisor will tell you that couples who discuss money openly have significantly lower divorce rates. This isnt just feelings, theres actual research on this. Financial secrecy correlates strongly with relationship breakdown. The data supports the original premise even if people dont like hearing it.
Separate accounts are just practical when one person has debt or a complicated financial past. My student loans are MY problem, not my partners. Keeping that separate protects both of us.
THANK YOU. Finally someone said it. You can share every bank account and still be strangers sleeping next to each other.
Hard disagree with the premise here. Financial autonomy ≠ emotional distance. These are completely separate things and conflating them is just bad reasoning.
This is a very Western, individualistic framing of what relationships should look like. In many cultures worldwide, finances are communal not just between spouses but across extended families. The assumption that "individual financial privacy" is some universal baseline right reflects a particular cultural lens, not a universal truth.
idk i feel like if i cant buy my girlfriend a surprise birthday present without her seeing the transaction then whats even the point of romance anymore lol. some privacy is just nice
Bro if you wont tell your spouse what you make just break up already lmao. Whats the point
The framing of salary as something to "hide" already loads the question unfairly. I don't "hide" that I prefer to sleep on the left side of the bed. I just haven't made it a formal disclosure. Some things are private by default, not by concealment.
Is it wrong to choose not to have children just because you don't want to?
110 comments
Would you still eat meat if you had to kill the animal yourself?
109 comments
Are dating apps genuinely harder for men or for women?
108 comments
Is judging someone by their height as shallow as judging by their weight?
108 comments